Yesterday in the newspaper, I read John McWhorter say,
that it was time for the ubiquitous “Comma” to be interred! According to him
there is no loss of clarity if the wee thing is murdered and buried without a
befitting burial! Rage engulfed me- remembering the- ifs and buts of the use of
comma that we learnt painstakingly from first grade onwards, Oh! Alas! The futile
toil of almost seventeen years of formal education and even beyond!
I am a lover of
English language, not because it’s smart but because that’s the only language I
know completely (as it possibly as can be). It is of course a vicious circle- I
love it because I know it, I know it as I love it! It is ever engulfing, though
its rules are rather atrocious, it is fluid and accepting. Over its long
history, plenty of words have been welcomed and accepted by it. It will remain
the language of the future and will not go the Latin or Sanskrit way. I love it
as it allows me to converse with the rest of the world, albeit sometimes using
my kind of sign language (which is largely gesticulating!) along with it, but I
get by….
Mr. Pico Iyer has given a very interesting view about
his love for the comma- he seems to be in love with it as much I am. So the
poor cousin of “full stop” does have its share of fans in the world. Where
would I be without its little pregnant pauses to give meaning to my private
poems? Where would I be without its meaningful breaks to thrust forward my
pugnacious arguments? Where would I be without its loud silences to take a
break from my stream of consciousness?
I quite agree with him that putting the comma into an
early grave will take out the romance and love from the English language. SMS
and Tweets are all right in that sphere of activity but in the serious and the
not so serious facets of the world, we need the softness of the “Comma” pause
as opposed to the harsh “full stop”!
All this ‘love’ and ‘romance’ and softness have brought
to my mind Valentine’s Day. It has been festering actually for the last one
week! I get at least thirty SMS from various brands about what I can gift my
Valentine, about the '50% off 'and sometimes 'up to 75% off 'on select merchandise,
and not to forget the ways to send hints to my valentine for gifting ideas.
I think the first mention of this highly amorous day, in
literature, was made in the fourteenth century by the father of English
language Geoffrey Chaucer (Parlement of Foules -1382). It, of course, has its
own little cameo in history and dates further down the line. I firmly believe
it was fished out of the darkness of obscurity by the “Archie’s Greetings” as a
major marketing ploy to distract the youth from their education and make their
parents pay for all the vulgarly expensive gifts. How else can you explain the
various “days” that are celebrated prior to the main day? The rose day, the hug
day, the teddy day, the kiss day and ……..Each day has its share of cards and
gifts to be bought.
The young people who are not at the receiving end are
looked upon with pity and horror by the others. They go through acute
depression and pangs of rejection. (Some parents are so scared that they send
cards to their own children as secret admirers!) Numbers of suicide and murder
cases are high during the week prior and after the ultimate day. The only
positive thing about this is, hopefully it distracts the youth from indulging
in marijuana (Which has been made legal in Colorado State!) and other such “elevating”
experiences.
I feel a little apprehensive of the present generation.
When we grew up, our crushes were private affairs. It’s not that there wasn’t romance;
it was as present as it is now, only it was subtle and much more exciting (I
wonder if each generation says that about their youth?) I do wonder what the
excitement is in necking in public. The little exchange of glances can create a
flutter in one’s heart. I do understand the high rate of divorce these days-
the couples just get bored of each other. They know each other for five to six
years before they marry and after that ennui sets in and it is time to part
ways.
The youth argue that they are much more honest in their relationships
then we were, but is that accurate and is that advisable? Romance is synonymous
with mystery, if we know the ins and outs of another human being, what is the challenge
to continue such an interaction? As human beings it is natural we search for
new experiences, new discoveries to keep our intellects alive. The game of relationships
is an interesting and time consuming activity. It is what separates us from
animals.
Love is a wonderful emotion; it’s not fair to commercialize
it. Valentine’s Day or a little note to be passed during class- let us keep it
on the right level; let us not put a price on a beautiful emotion and inculcate
the spirit of competition in every field of our lives. Some emotions are
sacred, calming, serene and healing; let us take out the knives and forks from
here as there is a possibility of getting hurt.
Both the “Comma” and “Valentine’s Day” celebrate
fidelity in their work sphere, one to language and one to love. Both bring a
pause to their work stations in their own way. The comma gives meaning and
depth to the pause, while V day suspends our minds for at least ten days. One
enhances the fluid dynamics of language; the other creates questions and doubts
about the devotion of our partners. Do not inter either of them, they are both necessary
to our existence and bring in the spice to an otherwise humdrum and bland life.